Have only 20 council houses been built this year? | Journal.ie

Houses and Homes - Coloured and Numbered Houses - 1-20 - PI

18 November 2015

Industry and public reaction to recent Government proposals to tackle the housing crisis has been mixed. Commentators have suggested that the most practical way to address spiraling public housing lists is for Local Authorities to build new social housing. A recent Journal.ie article demonstrates just how many barriers there are to delivery with Local Authorities nationwide completing just 20 social housing units in the first half of the year. Minister Alan Kelly has defended his Department’s performance citing figures for existing refurbished “voids” or existing vacant units coming back into use. However, these are not new homes and will have a limited benefit for the +90,000 or so people waiting for housing and 1,400 children currently homeless.

Historically low Local Authority house building over the past 4 years combined with a very low take up of NAMA units offered to Local Authorities for social housing means that supply has remained at very depressed levels. Over the past number of years Local Authorities have had resources cut and have lost technical staff, engineers and architects, the professionals who are able to procure housing units and manage a raft of regulatory changes.

In September 2015, Minister Alan Kelly “opted-in” previously exempt Local Authority construction projects under new administrative procedures. Complicated and time-consuming administrative SI.9 compliance procedures now apply to Local Authority residential projects. The time and cost for this “red-tape” will impact directly on the supply and delivery of social housing.

Minister Alan Kelly is struggling to complete just 22 modular houses by Christmas under cumbersome regulations that his own Department introduced in recent months. It is hard to see how the current administration can make any meaningful inroads to residential supply problems and the housing crisis affecting thousands of families all across the state.

  • The following article “Fact check: Have only 20 council houses been built this year?” Journal.ie 12 November 2015, confirms that just 20 council houses were built in the first half of this year. Extract off article  (see link here):

“THE GOVERNMENT HAS been criticised for reportedly delivering only 20 council houses in the first half of this year – all of which were completed in the first three months of 2015…

A grand total of zero had been delivered in quarter two according to the Department’s figures:

original

Source: Department of Environment

Last November, the government committed to supplying 35,000 additional social housing units – at a cost of €3.8 billion – over the next six years.

With just 20 delivered by the mid-point of this year, it’s unsurprising that AAA TD Ruth Coppinger [Anti-Austerity Alliance] lashed the government for the lack of progress as the housing crisis dominates the political agenda.

“How in the midst of the worst housing crisis in living memory can the government think that the building of council homes shouldn’t feature?” Coppinger said yesterday…These figures are shocking and shameful…

However, the Department of Environment hit back, insisting the figure of 20 – which is their own  – was “grossly out of date”…

Coppinger hit back today, pointing out that the government’s claim of the figures being “grossly out of date” didn’t stack up when they were published by the Department of Environment on 22 October – just three weeks ago.

TheJournal.ie submitted four fairly simple questions to the Department of Environment:

  • Exactly how many social houses were built in Q1 this year?
  • Exactly how many social houses were built in Q2 this year?
  • Exactly how may social houses were built in Q3 this year?
  • If Coppinger’s figures are “grossly out of date” can you provide the most up-to-date figures on the exact number of social houses built so far this year as opposed the number estimated for completion by year’s end?

The Department did not directly answer our questions in its response, nor did it dispute the eye-catching figure of only 20 council houses so far this year.

They told us that in deciding on targets, the social housing strategy determined that the new-build programme would be “slow in the initial phases of the strategy as the planning and design and tendering processes had to be progressed first”.

However the Department insisted that it was confident that 7,000 units will be delivered this year. The Department also repeated that there are currently 3,500 social houses under construction nationwide. 

In conclusion, it is correct to say that only 20 council houses were built in the first half of  2015. But the Department appears confident that it will have delivered significantly more than that by the end of the year and many more in the years ahead.”

Other posts of interest:

Plans for 35,000 social houses now in doubt?

Is Building Control a threat to Christmas completion of modular homes? | Vivian Cummins

What do Building Control Regulations cost for a typical apartment?

Number of homes being built in Dublin falling | Irish Times

RIAI President | “2 – 3 million hours a year to inspect new house building”

Phil Hogan’s Building Regulations… “were a step backwards”

Housing Completions Slump… only 5,625 new homes built in Q1+2 of 2015

Housing Crisis | NAMA funds €1.5m ‘trophy homes’?

Local Authorities take over fewer than 1,200 NAMA Housing units in four years

1 thought on “Have only 20 council houses been built this year? | Journal.ie

  1. Andrew Alexander MRIAI

    Modern governments in open free market “anglo saxon” economies such as Ireland’s do not want to touch social housing with a bargepole.

    While the “housing crisis” is touted as an elephant in the room for the sitting government the re-election strategy will be focused elsewhere – on the class of people who typically vote.

    When it comes to the issue of housing, the class of people who typically vote consist of;

    a) the class of people who already have property and have seen their assets rise (the first group),

    b) the class of people who are in negative equity and are being told to hang in there with the current strategy “soon enough you will be able to join the first group” and

    c) the class of people who are currently renting and are also being told “hang in there, our strategy is your only way to the first group”.

    None of these classes of people want to live in, aspire to live in or aspire to fund with their taxes the construction of large schemes of social housing.

    While some in government would like to be seen cutting the red tape for a shiny new development, no department in government (national or local) is resourced or has the appetite for the kind of management and responsibility that comes with looking after and maintaining 20,000 new homes.

    It is the same issue with SI.9. One hundred percent inspection would be “nice to have” but the bill to resource such a system in the employment of additional Local Authority Inspectors is too much to countenance.

    Consequently, in a political sense, legislation such as SI.9 can be dressed up as a private sector solution consistent with the spin of being an open “free market” economy.

    In this sense Ireland is much more right wing than Britain and will never have, as a priority, the construction of large numbers of social housing overseen by well staffed Local Building Control Authorities – the hearts of the government and the hearts of the people are not in it.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *