06 September 2017
Following on from a successful appeal by the Dublin Inquirer of a freedom of information refusal by the Department of Education (see story here), a fire safety report into six “Rapid” build schools was released last week. Katherine Donnelly and Paul Meila in the Independent article “School fire safety probe: Firm earned €40m from department and built modular houses for homeless Dublin families” report on the substantive issues (link here). A list of more than 35 schools completed or under construction currently by Western Building Systems is attached.
WBS have been contracted to provide seven more schools this year including schools in Kildare Town, Gorey, Co. Wexford, Letterkenny, Galway and two schools in Firhouse, Co Dublin. Extract of Independent article to follow:
The company at the centre of the schools fire safety probe has been paid more than €40m by the Department of Education since 2013 and also built 22 modular homes for homeless families.
The company is the owner of two non-compliant school buildings that it is leasing to the State.
It has also emerged that Co Tyrone-based Western Building Systems (WBS) has built 22 modular homes for Dublin City Council under a rapid build programme and is currently completing three schools projects in Dublin, Donegal and Galway.
Education Minister Richard Bruton is to seek legal advice after it emerged that four schools housing thousands of pupils, built by WBS in 2008, are subject to fire safety concerns.
Mr Bruton said … that he was “not satisfied” that remediation works ordered by his department had been completed by the firm.
All of the affected schools were built under a rapid delivery programme in 2008 by WBS, and were audited after breaches of fire safety rules were discovered and remedied at Rusk and Lusk Educate Together National School in 2014, which was also built by WBS. Fire safety inspections were carried out in January 2016, and reports finalised the following July. The Department of Education said the firm agreed to complete works in June last year, but that many remain incomplete.
Problems were identified in five schools: St Francis of Assisi Primary School and Belmayne Educate Together School, both in Belmayne, Co Dublin and which are owned by WBS and leased to the State; Mullingar Educate Together in Westmeath, Gaelscoil na gCloch Liath in Greystones, Co Wicklow, and a building at Powerstown Educate Together in Dublin, which has since been shut. The Department of Education plans to conduct audits of up to 30 more schools built by a range of developers to check for compliance with safety rules.
Department of Education records show that the firm was paid more than €40m since 2013 under the school building programme, and for renting property to the State. WBS said that all buildings met the relevant standards at the time they were handed over to the State, and that it could not be held responsible for works carried out by third parties in the meantime. It does not believe it is responsible “for issues that have presented themselves since the hand-overs”, but was working with the department to address concerns.
However, Mr Bruton said the works were being supervised by the department and local authority fire officers.
“My department will be taking legal advice in relation to queries we have had with these cases,” he said. “Our concern is for children’s safety.”
Meanwhile, a primary school built nine years ago is to be demolished because it is not fit for purpose. Rush and Lusk Educate Together National School is the sixth school where fire safety issues have been found.
A total of €900,000 was spent afterwards on structural issues and in terms of fire safety, the building is now completely safe. The only option now is to demolish and build a new school which will cost €5m-€7m.
Other schools by developer
- Firhouse Educate Together NS (on site)
- Firhouse Gaelscoil (on site)
- Galway Educate Together NS (pending)
- Kildare Gaelscoil Mhic Aodha NS (pending)
- Gorey St Joseph’s Primary School (pending)
- Letterkenny Educate Together NS
- Scoil Aoife CNS, Citywest
- Ashbourne Educate Together NS
- Ashbourne Gaelscoil na Mí
- Colaiste de Lacy, Ashbourne
- Scoil Chaitlin Maude, Tallaght
- Broombridge Educate Together NS
- Gaelscoil Shliabh Rua, Stepaside, Dublin
- St Colmans NS, Macroom, Co Cork
- Gaelscoil Thulach na nÓg
- Cara Junior Special School, Mayfield, Cork
- Luttrellstown CC, Porterstown, Dublin
- Scoil Choilm, Porterstown, Dublin
- Carrigaline Educate Together, Cork
- Gaelscoil Chloich na Coillte, Clonakilty, Cork
- Scoil Phádraig Naofa, Rochestown, Cork
- Portlaoise Educate Together, Co Laois
- Gaelscoil Portlaoise, Laois ¦ Maryborough CoI, Portlaoise, Co Laois
- Gaelscoil Eiscir Riada, Lucan, Dublin
- Scoil Naomh Lucais, Mulhuddart, Dublin
- Portarlington Convent National School, Co Laois
- Scoil Chormaic, Flemington, Balbriggan, Dublin
- Scoil Atha Í, Kildare ¦ Scoil Phadraig Naofa, Athy, Co Kildare
- Model School, Athy, Kildare Lucan East Educate Together, Dublin
- St Paul’s National School, Ratoath, Co Meath
- Tyrrellstown Educate Together, Dublin
- Ardgillan Community College, Balbriggan, Dublin
- Scoil Naomh Lucais (previously Mulhuddart national school), Tyrrellstown, Dublin
- Belmayne Educate Together/ St Francis of Assisi, Dublin (adjoining campus)
- Rush/ Lusk Educate Together, Dublin
- Greystones Educate Together/ Gaelscoil na gCloch Liath, Dublin (adjoining campus)
- Mullingar Educate Together, Co Westmeath
Other posts of interest: